UnitedHealth (UNH) has found itself under a harsh spotlight on Wall Street. Once a darling of defensive investors, UNH stock has been battered and bruised in 2025, tumbling nearly 40% year-to-date (YTD). Among S&P 500 Index ($SPX) constituents, it now ranks among the poorest performers, a dramatic shift for a company long considered a fortress in health insurance.

The trouble began with a disappointing earnings report earlier this year, which sparked fears of mounting costs and operational inefficiencies. Then came the one-two punch: UnitedHealth withdrew its forward guidance and announced a CEO shake-up. As if that were not enough, the U.S. Department of Justice reportedly began probing its billing practices, raising further red flags.

Right now, the question is no longer “what went wrong” but whether there is a light at the end of the tunnel. Some investors, contrarian by nature, argue that much of the damage has already been priced in. If these headwinds prove temporary, this bruised blue chip could offer a rare opportunity.

About UnitedHealth Stock

Headquartered in Minnesota, UnitedHealth is one of the most influential players in the U.S. healthcare system. The company operates a suite of offerings including health maintenance organizations, preferred provider organizations, point-of-service plans, and managed fee-for-service programs. 

As of now, UnitedHealth commands a market capitalization of $280 billion. However, its stock performance has been anything but steady. In the past three months alone, UNH has slipped 40%. From its 52-week high of $630.73, the drop extends to 50%, a fall that has rattled long-time shareholders.

Yet, beneath this decline lies a potential value proposition. Currently, UNH trades at 13.7 times forward adjusted earnings and just 0.69 times sales, Both of these valuation metrics sit well below their five-year historical averages, indicating potential upside for those willing to bet on a turnaround.

Adding to its appeal, UnitedHealth pays an annualized forward dividend of $8.51, offering a 2.75% yield. The company has also raised its dividend for 15 consecutive years. Its most recent quarterly dividend of $2.21 was paid on June 24 to shareholders who held the stock as of June 16.

UnitedHealth Misses on Q1 Earnings

On April 17, UnitedHealth reported its fiscal 2025 first-quarter earnings. The results left much to be desired. While revenue increased to $109.6 billion, growing 9.8% year-over-year (YOY), it fell short of Wall Street’s forecast of $111.13 billion. On the bottom line, adjusted EPS grew 4.2% from the prior year’s quarter to $7.20 but missed the expected $7.27 per share.

Diving deeper, earnings from operations rose to $9.1 billion, climbing 15% from a year earlier, while adjusted net earnings improved 3% to $6.6 billion. As of March 31, UnitedHealth held $34.3 billion in cash and short-term investments, up from $29.1 billion at the close of 2024.

But not all is smooth sailing. The company continues to wrestle with higher-than-anticipated cost pressures and spikes in utilization, especially within its Medicare Advantage segment. While these challenges have clearly unsettled the market, management remains resolute.

CEO Stephen Hemsley acknowledged that both external market forces and internal oversights played a role in the stumble. However, the CEO emphasized that the majority of issues are within the company’s power to correct. As part of its long-term strategy, UnitedHealth continues to focus on modernization and innovation, aiming to achieve earnings growth between 13% and 16% in the coming years.

The next key moment will arrive on Tuesday, July 29, when UnitedHealth announces its Q2 results before the market opens. Analysts forecast Q2 2025 EPS to fall 25% YOY to $5.08, while full fiscal year 2025 EPS is projected to decline 20% to $22.07. For fiscal 2026, EPS is expected to rebound by 15% to $25.39.

What Do Analysts Expect for UnitedHealth Stock?

Despite a rough start to 2025, analysts have not entirely soured on UnitedHealth. The stock currently carries a “Moderate Buy” consensus rating, suggesting that the Street sees light at the end of the tunnel.

Out of the 24 analysts covering UNH stock, 15 have a “Strong Buy,” two rate it as a “Moderate Buy,” and seven recommend a “Hold” for the stock for now. The average price target of $363.43 represents potential upside of 16%. Meanwhile, the Street-High target of $440 suggests a potential climb of 41% from current levels.

That said, patience remains a critical factor here. Analysts appear cautiously optimistic, holding onto belief in the company’s underlying fundamentals but staying wary of near-term volatility.